logo4 Evolution is progress—                          
progress is creativity.        
vline

Demarcation problem

view blog view wiki view wiki view wiki

Demarcation problem is an epistemological problem it exists as such since the time when rational thinking began. It is the problem to distinguish between science and pseudoscience, rational and irrational decision making.

Poper introduced falsifiability or refutability as demarcation criterion, so what is falsifiable is classified as scientific and vice versa [Error: Wrong macro arguments: "11881" for macro 'ref' (maybe wrong macro tag syntax?)] [Error: Wrong macro arguments: "11879" for macro 'ref' (maybe wrong macro tag syntax?)] . The introduction of that criterion fulfills two two requirements or surrogate parameters of evolutionary progress. These are decontextualization and slave fauceir content. That is depicted by the following two graphs.

G cluster_0 pseudoscience cluster_1 science a0 emotional decision b0 rational decision a0->b0 b0->a0

We consider the conflict or mutual control between rational and irrational decision making as a fauceir that undergoes evolutionary progress, so in the next picture an other fauceir, some people would call it a meme, is intercalated increasing both the distance between the combatants (an effect that we call decontextualization) and the overall complexity increasing the fauceir content.

G cluster_00 cluster_0 pseudoscience cluster_1 defense line cluster_2 science a0 emotional decision c0 falsifiability criterion a0->c0:c0 c0:c0->a0 b0 rational decision c0->b0 b0->c0

Furthermore, the fauceir approach to scientific discovery adds an other criterion, the axiomatic perspective.

G cluster_00 cluster_0 pseudoscience cluster_1 defense line cluster_3 axiomatic approach cluster_2 science a0 emotional decision c0 falsifiability criterion a0->c0 c0->a0 d0 axiomatic analysis c0->d0 d0->c0 b0 rational decision d0->b0 b0->d0

Unfortunately, it was impossible to 'convince' graphviz to draw a more instructive graph for reasons discussed here.

[Error: Macro 'references' doesn't exist]

Tags: Theory


Categories: Epistemology Philosophy

 
   

(c) Mato Nagel, Weißwasser 2004-2019, Disclaimer